Choosing the Right Pet Sitter: Questions to Ask and Factors to Consider

How to choose a pet sitter in Titusville... a Furriendly Critter Sitters sitter meeting a dog and its owner at home in Titusville, FL

Handing someone the key to your home is a big step, and most pet parents in Titusville make the choice with very little to go on. This checklist gives you eight questions to ask any pet sitter before you book, along with the answers Furriendly Critter Sitters gives, so you can hear what a clear answer sounds like.

Quick Answer

How to choose a pet sitter in Titusville comes down to eight checks: training, services, availability, reviews, a meet and greet, insurance and bonding, communication, and what the sitter does not offer. Ask each one before you book, and expect a clear, specific answer to every question from a sitter who knows the area.

How to Choose a Pet Sitter in Titusville Pet Parents Can Count On

A good sitter answers questions without hesitating. Use the eight below as a script for a phone call or a meet and greet, and write the answers down so you can compare two or three sitters side by side.

Titusville adds a few local factors. Many households work shifts at Kennedy Space Center or Cape Canaveral Space Force Station, where launch schedules don’t always line up with a pet’s dinner time. Florida heat from May through October shortens dog walks, and hurricane season runs June 1 to November 30. A sitter who knows the area has already thought about all three.

1. Training and Certifications

Ask about:

  • How long they have been pet sitting professionally
  • Pet first aid and CPR certification
  • Training in handling nervous, senior, or medicated pets

At Furriendly, founder Jen Jasmin has been pet sitting professionally since 2021. She is Fear Free Certified, a Pet Sitters International (PSI) member, and Pet First Aid & CPR certified, and she completes continuing education through Pet Center International, including coursework on medicating dogs and cats and recognizing heatstroke.

Those certifications belong to Jen personally. The sitters on her team learn through the Pet Care Team Training she runs for every new sitter.

2. Services and Animals

Ask about:

  • The kinds of animals they have cared for
  • Whether they give medication
  • Whether they offer the service you need: drop-in visits, dog walks, overnights, or farm care

Furriendly provides in-home pet sitting, dog walking, overnight and live-in care, and equine and farm animal care, and the team also cares for exotics such as rabbits, ferrets, and birds. A 30-minute drop-in covers feeding, fresh water, a potty break, any medication, and a photo update.

3. Availability and Backup Plan

Ask about:

  • Backup if the sitter gets sick the day before your trip
  • Weekend and holiday coverage
  • Storm season planning

Furriendly runs a team of four sitters. Holiday fees add $20 per day and cover holiday weekends and the full week between Christmas and New Year’s.

For storm season, the Hurricane Pet Safety Guide walks through planning for your pets.

4. Reviews From Other Clients

Ask about:

  • Where to read reviews from recent clients
  • How long clients have stayed with them

Furriendly Critter Sitters holds a 5.0 rating from 43 Google reviews as of October 2026. The rating sits alongside the rates and credentials in Furriendly Critter Sitters Reviews, Rates, and Credentials in Titusville, FL.

5. The Meet and Greet

Ask about:

  • Whether they meet your pets at home before the first visit
  • Whether the meet and greet has a charge
  • How they will learn your pet’s routine and care instructions

New Furriendly clients sign up through Time To Pet, schedule a free meet and greet, and book services at the meet and greet. Your pets, your home, and your routine are reviewed before any service starts.

6. Insurance, Bonding, and Background Checks

Ask about:

  • Insurance and bonding
  • Background checks for everyone who will enter your home

Insurance and bonding protect your home and belongings if something is damaged during a visit, and a background check tells you who is walking through your door. Every sitter on the Furriendly team is bonded, insured, and background-checked before visiting a home.

7. Updates After Each Visit

Ask about:

  • How you will hear how each visit went
  • Photos or a written report
  • How you can tell when the sitter arrived and left

Furriendly clients get a photo update and a visit report after every visit, and dog walks are GPS-tracked in Time To Pet, so you can see the route, the distance, and the start and end times.

8. What the Sitter Does Not Offer

Ask about:

  • Whether they board pets in their own home
  • Daycare or grooming

Furriendly does not offer boarding, daycare, or grooming. Every service happens in your pet’s own home, because staying put is easier on most animals than a new place.

Comparing a Sitter App With a Local Company

Many Titusville pet parents start on a sitter app. Furriendly covers that side by side in Why Titusville Pet Owners Are Ditching Rover, which is a good read before you compare answers.

What Pet Sitting Costs in Titusville

Whichever sitter you choose, ask for the rates in writing along with what each visit includes. Here are Furriendly’s rates:

Service What’s included Rate
Drop-in visit (30 min) Feeding, fresh water, potty break, medication, photo update $32 / visit
Drop-in visit (60 min) Everything above plus a walk, playtime, and extra attention $48 / visit
Overnight stay (evening to morning) Evening, overnight, and morning routine in your home $175 / night
Live-in care (24 hour) Around-the-clock presence in your home $275 / day
Bedtime tuck-in check Evening visit; the sitter does not stay overnight $85 / visit

 

Furriendly charges by time, and additional pets in the same household are covered within the visit. For a county-wide look at pricing, see The Cost of Pet Sitters in North Brevard County, FL.

Meet the Team Before You Decide

The best test of any sitter is meeting them. If you’d like to hear Furriendly’s answers to these eight questions in person, schedule your free meet and greet through Time To Pet.

Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Pet Sitter

Q: How do I choose a pet sitter in Titusville, FL?

A: Ask every sitter the same eight questions about training, services, availability, reviews, a meet and greet, insurance and bonding, communication, and what they do not offer. Compare the answers side by side, then meet your top choice at home with your pets before you book.

Q: What questions should I ask a pet sitter before hiring?

A: Start with how long they have been sitting professionally, whether they are certified in pet first aid and CPR, and whether they are insured, bonded, and background-checked. Then ask how they handle medication, what backup they have if they get sick, and how they report back after each visit.

Q: How much does a pet sitter cost in Titusville, FL?

A: Rates vary by sitter, so ask for them in writing along with what each visit includes. At Furriendly Critter Sitters, a 30-minute drop-in is $32, a 60-minute drop-in is $48, and an overnight stay is $175 per night.

Q: Should a pet sitter be insured and bonded?

A: Yes. Insurance and bonding protect your home and belongings if something is damaged during a visit. Every Furriendly sitter is bonded, insured, and background-checked before visiting a home.

Q: What happens at a pet sitter meet and greet?

A: The sitter meets you and your pets at home and reviews your pet’s routine, your home, and any care instructions before service starts. At Furriendly, the meet and greet is free, and services are booked at the meet and greet.

Q: Does Furriendly Critter Sitters offer boarding, daycare, or grooming?

A: No. Every Furriendly service takes place in your home or on your property, and the company does not offer boarding, daycare, or grooming.

Jennifer Jasmin

Jennifer Jasmin is the founder of Furriendly Critter Sitters and a U.S. military veteran. She has been pet sitting professionally since 2021 and founded the company in April 2022 with co-founder Corey Jasmin, also a U.S. military veteran. Jen is Fear Free Certified, a Pet Sitters International (PSI) member, and Pet First Aid & CPR certified, with multiple nutritional certifications and continuing education through Pet Center International. She leads a small, in-house-trained team serving Titusville, Mims, Port St. John, and the rest of Northern Brevard County... and yes, she will want to meet your fur baby.